Welcome to the Texas Board of Nursing

Board Meetings

Regular Meeting - April 16-17, 2015

Supplemental Agenda

All related meeting materials are available in Adobe Acrobat format

CALL TO ORDER - 8:30 a.m.

REVIEW OF AGENDA (pdf)

REVIEW OF THE MINUTES: January 22-23, 2015 Board Meeting

CONSENT AGENDA:

  • 1.2.1. Update of Pending Litigation in the Matters of:
    Ex Parte Brian Zalesky, Cause No. D-1-EX-09-000516, 427th Judicial District Court, Travis County, Texas;
    Bernardino Pedraza, Jr. vs. Texas State Board of Nursing, Cause No. C-2541-10-B; In the 93rd Judicial District,
    Hidalgo County; Texas;
    Rodney Wayne Hicks vs. Texas Board of Nursing, and in their official capacities only, Katherine Thomas, Executive
    Director, and Kristin K. Benton, President of the Board, Cause No. Cause No. D-1-GN-12-003118, in the 353rd
    Judicial District Court, Travis County, Texas;
    Stanley Payne, Plaintiff, vs. Texas Board of Nurse Examiners a/k/a Texas Board of Nursing, Defendant, Cause
    No. D-1-GN-12-003072, in the 126th Judicial District Court, Travis County, Texas;
    Jane Otieno vs. Texas Board of Nursing, Cause No. D-1-GN-13-002487, In the 201st District Court, Travis County, Texas;
    Darlene Moriarity vs. Texas Board of Nursing, Cause No. D-1-GN-14-002410, In the 53rd District Court, Travis
    County, Texas; and
    Davina Danielle Moore vs. Texas Board of Nursing, D-1-GN-14-002109, In the 126th District Court, Travis County, Texas.
    The Board Reserves the Right to Convene in Executive Session, if Necessary, Pursuant to §551.071(1), Texas
    Government Code, to Discuss Pending or Contemplated Litigation in these Matters.
  • 2.1. Financial Statement - 2ND Quarter, Fiscal Year 2015 - MMajek/LPerez
  • 2.2. Continuing Education Pre-Renewal Audit Report - 2ND Quarter, Fiscal Year 2015 - MMajek
  • 3.1.1. Promoting Competency Report - BCone
  • 3.2.1. Status Report on New Nursing Education Programs and Active and Potential Proposals - JHooper
  • 3.2.2. Status Report on Programs with Sanctions - JHooper
  • 3.2.3. Report on Communication Activities with Nursing Education Programs - SEmerson
  • 3.2.4. Report of Survey Visits
  • 3.2.5. Consideration of Change in Approval Status from Full Approval with Warning to Full Approval
  • 3.2.6. Consideration of Notification of Transfer of Administrative Control - University of Houston-Victoria Baccalaureate Degree Nursing Education Program in Sugar Land, Texas - JHooper
  • 3.2.7. Report of NCLEX-PN® Examination Pass Rates for 2014 - JHooper
  • 4.1. Criminal Background Check Update - TDiggs
  • 4.2. Report on Enforcement’s Initiative to Address Complaint Backlog - TDiggs
  • 5.1.1. Eligibility and Disciplinary Committee - JWJohnston
  • 5.1.2. Quarterly Statistical Report - 2ND Quarter, Fiscal Year 2015 - MMajek/KThomas
  • 7.1.1. TPAPN Quarterly Report - MVanDoren
  • 7.1.2. Texas Peer Assistance Program for Nurses Third Party Referral Report - TDiggs
  • 7.2. Health Professions Council Annual Report for Fiscal Year 2014 - KThomas
  • 8.1. Agreed Orders
  • 8.2. Agreed Orders - KSTAR Program
  • 8.3. Deferred Agreed Orders
  • 8.4. Reinstatement Agreed Orders
  • 8.5. Eligibility Agreed Orders
  • 8.6. ALJ Proposals for Decision
  • 8.6.1. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent
    Certificate RN #655699, Issued to JOEL MANZANO ATIENZA, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1127- JAbel
  • 8.6.5. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent
    Certificate LVN #208718, Issued to JENNIFER DENISE CARPENTER, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1125-
    JAbel
  • 8.7. Default ALJ Proposals for Decision
    • 8.7.1. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #582396, Issued to ELIZABETH ANN FOX, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1078- JAbel
    • 8.7.2. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of AP #112733 and Permanent Certificate RN #651668 and Prescriptive Authority #5188, Issued to SAMUEL JERIDEAU, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0820- JAbel
    • 8.7.3. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #655932, Issued to SUSAN RENEE JONES, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0514- JAbel
    • 8.7.4. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificates RN #730201 & LVN #175827, Issued to FELICIA LASHAWN JORDAN, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1420- JAbel
    • 8.7.5. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #465712, Issued to JOY A. UPHAM, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0746- JAbel
    • 8.7.6. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #233922, Issued to DIONNE DARLYSHA WILLIAMS, SOAH Docket No.
      507-15-1246- JAbel
    • 8.7.7. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #833283, Issued to GREGORY WAYNE WILLMON JR., SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0821- JAbel
    • 8.7.8. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #789707, Issued to VICTORIA ELAINE WILT, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1410- JAbel .


1. ADMINISTRATION

  • *1.1. Executive Director’s Report - KThomas
  • 1.2. Legal - JWJohnston
    • C *1.2.1. Update of Pending Litigation in the Matters of:
      Ex Parte Brian Zalesky, Cause No. D-1-EX-09-000516, 427th Judicial District Court, Travis
      County, Texas;
      Bernardino Pedraza, Jr. vs. Texas State Board of Nursing, Cause No. C-2541-10-B; In the 93rd
      Judicial District, Hidalgo County; Texas;
      Rodney Wayne Hicks vs. Texas Board of Nursing, and in their official capacities only, Katherine Thomas, Executive Director, and Kristin K. Benton, President of the Board, Cause No. Cause No. D-1-GN-12-003118, in the 353rd Judicial District Court, Travis County, Texas;
      Stanley Payne, Plaintiff, vs. Texas Board of Nurse Examiners a/k/a Texas Board of Nursing, Defendant, Cause No. D-1-GN-12-003072, in the 126th Judicial District Court, Travis County, Texas;
      Jane Otieno vs. Texas Board of Nursing, Cause No. D-1-GN-13-002487, In the 201st District Court, Travis County, Texas;
      Darlene Moriarity vs. Texas Board of Nursing, Cause No. D-1-GN-14-002410, In the 53rd District Court, Travis County, Texas; and
      Davina Danielle Moore vs. Texas Board of Nursing, D-1-GN-14-002109, In the 126th District Court, Travis County, Texas.
      The Board Reserves the Right to Convene in Executive Session, if Necessary, Pursuant to §551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to Discuss Pending or Contemplated Litigation in these Matters.
  • *1.2.2. Comparison of Texas Peer Assistance Program Order to Board of Nursing Staff Monitored Board Order - JWJohnston/TDiggs
  • *1.3. Legislative Update - KThomas/BHolter

2. OPERATIONS

3. NURSING

4. ENFORCEMENT

5. COMMITTEE REPORTS

  • 5.1. Board Committees
  • 5.2. Advisory Committees/Task Forces
    • 5.2.1. Advanced Practice Nursing Advisory Committee - KShipp/SCopely/NBinkley
    • 5.2.2. Nursing Practice Advisory Committee - KLHorn/MDavis/DBenbow/CStelly
    • 5.2.3. Advisory Committee on Education - KBenton/VAyars
    • 5.2.4. Advisory Committee on Licensure, Eligibility and Discipline- DBell/TCowen/JWJohnston/ JAbel
    • 5.2.5. Task Force to Study Implications of the Growth of Texas Nursing Education Programs - KBenton
  • 5.3. Collaboration with Outside Agencies/Stakeholders
    • 5.3.1. Statewide Health Coordinating Council Texas Center for Nursing Workforce Studies Advisory Committee - KThomas
    • 5.3.2. Updates Related to the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board and the Texas Workforce Commission - KBenton/JHooper
    • 5.3.3. National Council of State Boards of Nursing - Taxonomy of Error Root Cause Analysis of Practice (TERCAP) - SCaddell
      • 5.3.3.a.Texas - Taxonomy of Error Root Cause Analysis of Practice (TERCAP) Update - DBenbow/KBenton/MBThomas
    • 5.3.4. Texas Team Report - Robert Wood Johnson Initiative - KThomas
    • 5.3.5. National Council of State Boards of Nursing - KThomas
      • 5.3.5.a. Report on the National Council of State Boards of Nursing Mid-Year Meeting held March 16-
        18, 2015, Louisville, KY - KShipp/DBell/KThomas
      • 5.3.5.b. Appointment of Delegates to Attend the NCSBN Special Delegate Assembly to be held May
        4, 2015, in Chicago, IL - KShipp
      • 5.3.5.c. Appointment of Members to Attend the NCSBN Annual Meeting, to be held August 19-21,
        2015, in Chicago, IL - KShipp

OPEN FORUM: Thursday, 1:30 p.m. - 2:00 p.m.


6. OLD BUSINESS

7. NEW BUSINESS

8. PROPOSED BOARD ORDERS

  • C *8.1. Agreed Orders
    Aguilar, Rebecca RN# 787849
    Akwanga, Edwin Taji RN# 783413/ LVN# 221058
    Allison, Heather Diane RN# 776259
    Anastasio, James E. RN# 532550/ LVN# 111421
    Arias, Jorge LVN# 314288
    Baker, Brenda Jo RN# 581391
    Ballard, Shontivas Shree RN# 808923
    Bayes, Samantha Leeann RN# 826438
    Beaumont, Hapatia E. RN# 655417
    Benitez, Aubin RN# 794684/ LVN# 214432
    Bogue (Middleton), Medeanna D. RN# 532882/ LVN# 73477
    Bradford, Tonya Latrese LVN# 314268
    Cabotaje, Elizabeth Zaragosa RN# 793599
    Calvin, Lana K. LVN# 155087
    Camacho, Miguel Angel LVN# 224629/ RN Exam Petitioner
    Cantrell, Chase Mitchell RN# 795673
    Carmichael, Melissa Rene LVN# 147508
    Carter, Beth Ann RN# 763103
    Chenoweth, Frank B. RN# 532926
    Connally, Tammy Lynn LVN# 149860
    Cooper, Anita Marie LVN# 165696
    Correa, Edgardo RN# 646047
    Coss, Mark Allen RN# 802331/ LVN# 197340
    Cuellar, Delicia G. LVN# 180536
    Diaz, Remigia RN# 571614/ LVN# 92531
    Egwim. Mukosolu J. LVN# 320773
    Favela, Talia Lynn RN# 737881
    Felix, Nirmala George RN# 767476
    Frawner, Michelle Ryan RN# 810831/ LVN# 211939
    French, Patti Elizabeth AP# AP114091/RN# 553683
    Garza, Christine Marie RN# 621403
    Garza, Kristen Leann LVN# 225927
    Green, Carol A. AP# AP100656/RN# 243459
    Green-Heck, Melissa ND PTP / RN# R36741
    Goodwin, Becky Lynn LVN# 82396
    Han-Davila, Terexa RN# 774822
    Harris, Donna Lucy LVN# 173997
    Hawkins, M. Kathleen RN# 257501
    Heintz, Kimberly Jo RN# 769752
    Hickman, Dallas Jircik RN# 694514/ LVN# 171716
    Hinds, Jason RN# 651649/ LVN# 160484
    Holub, Ramona Gaytan RN# 663909/ LVN# 159251
    Kaye, Denise Ann RN# 563138
    Lacy, Robert LVN# 317235
    Lidikay, Lois Jean LVN# 170276
    Lopez, Christopher RN# 714275
    Lyman, David Lee RN# 785703
    McDonnell, Marian Patricia RN# 544615
    Machen, Louisa Sonora RN# 737067
    Marsh, Ashly Nicole RN# 821041
    Martinez, Ralph Perez LVN# 83396
    Miller, Sherry Jean LVN# 154948
    Oliver, Cathryn Ann RN# 727610/LVN# 168196
    Oluoch, Kennedy Odhiambo LVN# 313494
    Oranga, Gordon Odhiambo RN# 802518
    Padilla, Joey LVN# 212649
    Pennington, Cheryl J. RN# 509752
    Perez, Janice L. LVN# 110673
    Pierce, Jason Dean LVN# 320883/ RN Exam Petitioner
    Pinder, Laura Jillene LVN# 161187
    Presher, Kathleen Michelle LVN# 322764
    Ragin, Lauren RN# 789620
    Rasmussen, Carolyn Ann LVN# 191899
    Remes, Christian RN# 786115/ LVN# 219585
    Robles, Jr., Israel LVN# 198795
    Rodgers, Ronda Porter LVN# 309161
    Rodriguez, Hope Garcia LVN# 84389
    Sands, Lillian Angele RN# 660190
    Santos, Marisela LVN# 231735
    Sharpe, Ann Elise RN# 681405/ LVN# 176767
    Sparks, Stephen RN# 638817
    Taylor, Kathryn Janette RN# 730899
    Turner, Billi J. RN# 534947
    Vandenberg, Vitus Mayer NM PTP RN# R45786/RN Endorsement Petitioner
    Vandivere, Susan Gale LVN# 200802
    Weese, Roxanne Michelle LVN# 309176
    White, Betty Nell RN# 242210

  • C *8.2. Agreed Orders-KSTAR Program
    Bass, Kathy Jacobs RN# 538720
    Johnson, Barbara Ann LVN# 200547
    Ngwa, Nina Neh RN# 796225
    Salinas, Monica Irene RN# 704082

  • C *8.3. Deferred Agreed Orders
    Lubojacky, Cassandra Marie RN# 780647

  • C *8.4. Reinstatement Agreed Orders
    Ballentine, Sally Lynn RN# 603237
    Hackley, Robert James RN# 711136
    Johnson, Simone Yvette LVN# 196749
    Ricks, Alison Leann LVN# 183824
    Rogers, Cassandra Renee LVN# 193516

  • C *8.5. Eligibility Agreed Orders
    Aldana, Deanna Michele RN Exam Petitioner
    Cook, Garrette Michael RN Endorsement Petitioner
    Duruji, Mandela O. RN Exam Petitioner
    Guajardo, Blanca Pamela LVN Exam Petitioner
    Gutierrez, Jesusa Deleon LVN Exam Petitioner
    Henderson, Nikita De'Shawn RN Exam Petitioner
    Lopes (Gomez), Oralia LVN Exam Petitioner
    McPherson, William LVN Exam Petitioner
    Magers (Dabbs), Melissa Ann LVN Exam Petitioner
    Ojeda (Perez), Marilena Delores RN Endorsement Petitioner
    Ray, Kayleen RN Exam Petitioner
    Reyna, Donna Lee LVN Exam Petitioner
    Roberts, Bryan Pierce LVN Exam Petitioner
    Scott, Christopher David LVN Exam Petitioner
    Villanueva, Deon Arazth RN Exam Petitioner

  • 8.6. ALJ Proposals for Decision
    • *8.6.1. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of
      Permanent Certificate RN #655699, Issued to JOEL MANZANO ATIENZA, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1127- JAbel
      • 8.6.1.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #655699, Issued to JOEL MANZANO ATIENZA, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1127
    • *8.6.2. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #772621, Issued to AMY JEANETTE BANDA, SOAH Docket No. 507- 14-4135- JAbel
      • 8.6.2.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #772621, Issued to AMY JEANETTE BANDA, SOAH Docket No. 507-14-4135
    • *8.6.3. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of
      Permanent Certificates RN #794686 & LVN #124412, Issued to BRANDY DAWN BLANCHARD,
      SOAH Docket No. 507-14-4775- JAbel
      • 8.6.3.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificates RN #794686 & LVN #124412, Issued to BRANDY DAWN BLANCHARD, SOAH Docket No. 507-14-4775
    • *8.6.4. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #593893, Issued to JOHN THOMAS CAHAK, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0467- JAbel
      • 8.6.4.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #593893, Issued to JOHN THOMAS CAHAK, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0467
    • C *8.6.5. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #208718, Issued to JENNIFER DENISE CARPENTER, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1125- JAbel
      • 8.6.5.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #208718, Issued to JENNIFER DENISE CARPENTER, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1125
    • *8.6.6. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #246301, Issued to ZANZETTA A. FRANKLIN, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0951- JAbel
      • 8.6.6.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #246301, Issued to ZANZETTA A. FRANKLIN, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0951
    • *8.6.7. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #124114, Issued to CHERYL LYNN MCWHORTER, SOAH Docket No. 507-14-2624- JAbel
      • 8.6.7.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #124114, Issued to CHERYL LYNN MCWHORTER, SOAH Docket No. 507-14-2624
    • *8.6.8. Consideration of Proposal For Decision, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #198556, Issued to AHMED KHOSRAVI-NEJAT, SOAH Docket No. 507-14-3701- JAbel
      • 8.6.8.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #198556, Issued to AHMED KHOSRAVI-NEJAT, SOAH Docket No. 507-14-3701

  • 8.7. Default ALJ Proposals for Decision
    • C *8.7.1. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the
      Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #582396, Issued to ELIZABETH ANN FOX, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1078- JAbel
      • 8.7.1.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or
        contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #582396, Issued to ELIZABETH ANN FOX, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1078
    • C *8.7.2. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of AP #112733 and Permanent Certificate RN #651668 and Prescriptive Authority #5188, Issued to SAMUEL JERIDEAU, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0820- JAbel
      • 8.7.2.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of AP #112733 and Permanent Certificate RN #651668 and Prescriptive Authority #5188, Issued to SAMUEL JERIDEAU, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0820
    • C *8.7.3. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #655932, Issued to SUSAN RENEE JONES, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0514- JAbel
      • 8.7.3.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #655932, Issued to SUSAN RENEE JONES, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0514
    • C *8.7.4. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificates RN #730201 & LVN #175827, Issued to FELICIA LASHAWN JORDAN, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1420- JAbel
      • 8.7.4.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificates RN #730201 & LVN #175827, Issued to FELICIA LASHAWN JORDAN, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1420
    • C *8.7.5. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #465712, Issued to JOY A. UPHAM, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0746- JAbel
      • 8.7.5.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #465712, Issued to JOY A. UPHAM, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0746
    • C *8.7.6. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #233922, Issued to DIONNE DARLYSHA WILLIAMS, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1246- JAbel
      • 8.7.6.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate LVN #233922, Issued to DIONNE DARLYSHA WILLIAMS, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1246
    • C *8.7.7. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #833283, Issued to GREGORY WAYNE WILLMON JR., SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0821- JAbel
      • 8.7.7.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #833283, Issued to GREGORY WAYNE WILLMON JR., SOAH Docket No. 507-15-0821
    • C *8.7.8. Consideration of Order of Dismissal and Remand, Recommendations, and Board action: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #789707, Issued to VICTORIA ELAINE WILT, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1410- JAbel
      • 8.7.8.a. Executive Session pursuant to 551.071(1), Texas Government Code, to discuss pending or contemplated litigation: In the Matter of Permanent Certificate RN #789707, Issued to VICTORIA ELAINE WILT, SOAH Docket No. 507-15-1410

9. MISCELLANEOUS

  • 9.1. Board Items of Interest for Future Board Meetings
  • 9.2. Board Development: Presentation by John M. Lehman, PhD, on the DSM V
  • *9.3. Review of the Board Quarterly Meeting Evaluation - KShipp
  • 9.4. Executive Director and Board Evaluations - KShipp/KThomas

* - Written materials Sent from Office
** - Written materials Sent from third party
C - Item is placed on consent (no discussion of the material(s) required)